2266 HORSE THIEF Road, Overgaard, AZ 85933 (MLS# 6870351)

2266 HORSE THIEF Road, Overgaard, AZ 85933

$125,000

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 1 Baths: 1 Square Footage: 500 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 2,389 Status: Closed

Current Price: $125,000 Last Modified: 4/05/2026

Description

Discover your perfect mountain escape with this charming Pinecrest Lake park model, nestled among towering tall pines. Step onto a spacious covered deck—ideal for relaxing or entertaining—and enjoy the convenience of a utility shed for extra storage. Inside, a bright open-concept kitchen, dining, and living area creates a warm, welcoming space, complete with an in-unit washer and dryer. Cozy up with propane heat, stove, and water heater for year-round comfort. Low HOA fees include water and clubhouse access, plus a serene catch-and-release pond for leisurely afternoons. Comfort, beauty, and tranquility await—your peaceful retreat starts here.

More Information MLS# 6870351

Contract Information

Type: Exclusive Right To Sell Ownership: Fee Simple Co-Ownership (Fractional) Agreement YN: No Sold Price: $125,000 Status: Closed Current Price: $125,000 List Date: 2025-05-23

Location, Tax & Legal

Assessor's Map #: 42 Legal Description (Abbrev): LOT 156 PINECREST LAKE Assessor's Parcel #: 156 Tax Municipality: Navajo - COUNTY Taxes: 400 House Number: 2266 Street Name: HORSE THIEF St Suffix: Road City/Town Code: Overgaard State/Province: AZ Zip Code: 85933 Zip4: 5202 County Code: Navajo Assessor Number: 206-42-156 Subdivision: PINECREST LAKE Tax Year: 2024

General Property Description

Dwelling Styles: Detached # of Interior Levels: 1 Approx SQFT: 500 Price/SqFt: 250 Approx Lot SqFt: 2389 Approx Lot Acres: 0.055 Horses: N Builder Name: Cavco Elementary School District: Heber-Overgaard Unified District High School District: Heber-Overgaard Unified District Elementary School: Capps Elementary School Jr. High School: Mogollon Jr High School High School: Mogollon High School Community Pool Y/N: No Private Pool Y/N: No Fireplace YN: No Dwelling Type: Mfg/Mobile Housing Exterior Stories: 1 # Bedrooms: 1 Total Bathrooms: 1 Year Built: 1994

Legal Info

Range: 17E Section: 33 Township: 12N Lot Number: 156

Special Listing Cond

N/A: 1

Construction

Wood Frame: 1

Const - Finish

Other (See Remarks): 1

Roofing

Composition: 1

Association & Fees

HOA Y/N: Y HOA Disclosure/Addendum Affirmation: Yes HOA Transfer Fee: 100 HOA Fee: 936 HOA Paid Frequency: Annually HOA Name: Pinecrest Lake HOA HOA Telephone: 928-537-1067 ext 140 HOA Management Company: HOAMCO Special Assessment HOA: No HOA 2 Y/N: N PAD Fee Y/N: N Cap Improvement/Impact Fee: 375 Cap Improvement/Impact Fee $/%: $ Prepaid Association Fees HOA: 0 Disclosure Fees HOA: 200 Other Fees HOA: 200 Other Fees Description: HOAMCO Transfer Fee Land Lease Fee Y/N: N Rec Center Fee Y/N: N Ttl Mthly Fee Equiv: 78

Showing Notification Methods

Showing Service: Non-MLS Showing Service - See Private Remarks Text: 1 Email: 1 Phone Call: 1

Lockbox Type

See Private Remarks: 1

Master Bathroom

Full Bth Master Bdrm: 1

Master Bedroom

Downstairs: 1

Flooring

Carpet: 1 Laminate: 1

Window Features

Dual Pane: 1

Community Features

Clubhouse/Rec Room: 1 Coin-Op Laundry: 1

Dining Area

Eat-in Kitchen: 1

Heating

Propane: 1

Kitchen Features

Gas Oven: 1 Gas Range: 1 Built-in Microwave: 1 Refrigerator: 1

Cooling

Ceiling Fan(s): 1

Interior Features

Furnished(See Rmrks): 1

Laundry

Washer Included: 1 Dryer Included: 1 Inside: 1

Basement

Basement Y/N: N

Separate Den/Office

Sep Den/Office Y/N: N

Road Responsibility

Private Maintained Road: 1

Fencing

None: 1

Water Source

Pvt Water Company: 1

Exterior Features

Private Street(s): 1

Spa

None: 1

Manufactured Home Features

Single Wide: 1

Sewer

Sewer - Private: 1

Parking Spaces

Slab Parking Spaces: 0 Total Covered Spaces: 0

New Financing

Cash: 1 Conventional: 1

Plumbing

Gas Hot Water Heater: 1

Utilities

City Electric: 1 Propane: 1

Existing 1st Loan

Treat as Free&Clear: 1

Landscaping

Natural Desert Front: 1 Natural Desert Back: 1

Unit Style

All on One Level: 1

Contact Info

List Agent Home Phn: 928-535-3939

Disclosures

Seller Discl Avail: 1 Agency Discl Req: 1

Residential Propane Tank

Residential Propane Tank: Leased

Possession

Close of Escrow: 1

Association Fee Incl

Water: 1 Sewer: 1 Common Area Maint: 1 Street Maint: 1

Assoc Rules/Info

Prof Managed: 1

Sold Info

Loan Type: Conventional Loan Years: 30 Closing Cost Split: Normal - N Payment Type: Fixed Buyer Concession to Seller: 0 Buyer Concession $/%: $ Seller Concession to Buyer: 0 Seller Concession $/%: $

Remarks Misc

Cross Street: Hwy 260 and Pony Express Rd Directions: Hwy 260, R on Pony Express Rd, L on Old Crooks Trail, L on Stagecoach Blvd, R on Horse Thief to property on L at sign. Geo Lat: 34.387982 Geo Lon: -110.543775

Status Change Info

Off Market Date: 2025-07-30 Under Contract Date: 2025-07-29 Close of Escrow Date: 2025-08-22 Sold Price: $125,000

Property Features

Special Listing Cond: N/A Master Bathroom: Full Bth Master Bdrm Master Bedroom: Downstairs Flooring: Carpet; Laminate Window Features: Dual Pane Spa: None Community Features: Clubhouse/Rec Room; Coin-Op Laundry Dining Area: Eat-in Kitchen Kitchen Features: Gas Oven; Gas Range; Built-in Microwave; Refrigerator Laundry: Washer Included; Dryer Included; Inside Interior Features: Furnished(See Rmrks) Exterior Features: Private Street(s) Manufactured Home Features: Single Wide Road Responsibility: Private Maintained Road Construction: Wood Frame Const - Finish: Other (See Remarks) Roofing: Composition Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s) Heating: Propane Plumbing: Gas Hot Water Heater Utilities: City Electric; Propane Water Source: Pvt Water Company Sewer: Sewer - Private Fencing: None Landscaping: Natural Desert Front; Natural Desert Back Showing Notification Methods: Text; Email; Phone Call Lockbox Type: See Private Remarks Possession: Close of Escrow Unit Style: All on One Level Association Fee Incl: Water; Sewer; Common Area Maint; Street Maint Existing 1st Loan: Treat as Free&Clear New Financing: Cash; Conventional Disclosures: Seller Discl Avail; Agency Discl Req

Listing Office: Diane Dahlin's Pine Rim Realty

Last Updated: April - 05 - 2026